Presenting to the board: what the people across the table wish you knew
Earlier this month RNZ reported an $11.8 million deficit, against a forecast loss of about $470,000. Its board has said it didn't know the true position until October, and an independent review is now working out how that happened. I don't know what went wrong there, and I won't guess before the review reports.
But it got me thinking about presenting to boards, and how much rides on clear, concise communication in that room.
In my work I talk about stepping into the spotlight, and a board's is one of the brightest there is. It's meant to be. A board is there to exercise judgement and governance over what management brings it, so its job is to light up every part of your proposal, including the parts you'd rather stayed in shadow. The room is senior. The decisions are big, and so are the consequences.
So the better something is explained, the better the questions a board can ask about it. A board can only govern well what it has understood. Whether you're advocating for something, asking for something or giving an update, your job is to explain it clearly enough that the people across the table can test it properly and make a good decision for the organisation. And to be at ease in that light while they do.
First, have they told you what they want?
Every board is different in how it wants things presented. So before anything else, two questions. Have they given you a brief: a template, a time limit, a rule about slides? And if they haven't, have you asked? The chair, the chief executive or the board secretary can usually tell you what works for this board. Ask how the board likes information presented to it. Do they want an executive summary and then discussion? Do they just want to ask questions? Very few presenters ask.
There are two things I always want to know before planning anything. Will this board be asked to decide something? And will they get a pre-read? The answers change how you open, how you close and how long you talk.
Ask about the culture of the room, too. Plenty of boards here open with a karakia or a mihi. An iwi organisation, a council, a co-operative and a family company each run their meetings differently. Know what you're walking into.
If there's a brief, follow it. Give the audience what they've asked for.
That doesn't mean the brief is a good one. But turn up with something else and you risk hearing "this isn't what we asked for" two minutes in, and spending the rest of your time being steered back to what they wanted. Few presentations recover from that.
If you think the brief gets in the way, you have options. Do it their way and do it well. Ask beforehand whether a different approach would be welcome. Or deliver it as asked and suggest a change afterwards. Which one is right depends on the board, its culture and where you stand with it. Use your judgement.
What comes up consistently
With that said, some things hold for most boards. A board isn't like any other audience you'll present to. They've read your paper, or they were meant to. They have a different job from any other audience. Their job is to test what you've brought them and then make a decision they're personally accountable for. Under our Companies Act, directors can rely on what management tells them only if they make proper inquiry where the circumstances call for it. So the hard questions are the job, and nothing personal. Julie Garland McLellan, the Australian director who wrote Presenting to Boards, is blunt about it: this isn't a conference talk, and it certainly isn't a sales pitch.
I've spent twenty years coaching people for that room. What follows is what has come up again and again with them, checked against what directors and governance bodies here, in Australia and further afield say they want. Reassuringly, we all agree.
1. Start with where they are, not where you are
Everything we teach rests on one idea: a presentation moves an audience from their Point A to your Point B. With a board, Point A is easy to get wrong. They aren't in the business every day. They may have had half an hour with your topic, and it was competing with a couple of hundred other pages. The Institute of Directors gives the same advice to anyone writing a board paper: assume little, because directors only see the organisation a few times a year.
So before you write anything, ask three questions. What does this board already know? What's worrying them? And what have they been burnt by before?
2. Say what you want in the first minute
The presenter I've met most often over twenty years is the one I call the Informer: all the facts, and no idea what they want the room to do with them. Boards see a lot of Informers.
Point B is the cure. It's what you want this board to think, feel and do by the time you leave, and with a board the "do" is usually a decision. We call the short version the Big Idea: three sentences or fewer, the situation first and then the ask. "Growth at home has flattened, and our biggest customers want us supplying them in Australia. Management recommends buying a distributor there rather than building from scratch. We're asking you to approve due diligence and a non-binding offer today."
The UK's Chartered Governance Institute and Board Intelligence published new guidance on board reporting in July this year, and it says the same: tell the board plainly whether you want them to note, to decide or to give input. Rick Christie, a long-serving New Zealand chair, told the IoD's Boardroom magazine in 2017 that boards hate too much detail too early. Main points first, the rest in the appendix.
3. Don't present the paper. Don't rely on it either.
There are two ways to get this wrong. One is to walk the board through a paper they've already been sent. The other is to assume they've all read it, skip the point and go straight to the detail.
The first wastes the time of the directors who did their reading. The second loses the ones who didn't, and there will be some. Research this year from the UK's Chartered Governance Institute and Board Intelligence put the average board pack at 220 pages, and 63 per cent of the people surveyed weren't confident their pack had been fully read.
So open with your idea and your ask in a few sentences, whether or not they've read it. Then use your time for what the paper can't do: what has changed since you wrote it, where the real judgement call sits, and how sure you are.
4. Plan to talk for half your time
PwC's Paul DeNicola and Claudia Montgomery advise executives to speak for no more than half their slot and keep the rest for discussion. Dr Judith MacCormick, writing for the Australian Institute of Company Directors, allows two-thirds, and adds a good one: have a five-minute version ready for when the agenda runs over.
It will run over, and your slot is what gets squeezed. Garland McLellan suggests one slide that states the purpose and the ask, and no more than three with data. You may not need any.
5. Your Obstacles are their questions
On our Planning Canvas, after Point A and Point B, comes the section most people skip: the Obstacles. What's stopping this board getting to Point B? A competing priority. A budget already spoken for. Something similar that went badly three years ago. A director who has seen it all before.
Write them down and you've written most of the questions you're about to be asked. Then go and find out whether you're right. Garland McLellan and the PwC pair both recommend a conversation beforehand with the chair, the chief executive or the board secretary about what's on directors' minds. Pip Greenwood, one of New Zealand's most experienced directors, lists "no surprises" among the things boards want from the people who advise them. It works in both directions.
6. Bring the bad news yourself
Mark Hamilton, a New Zealand director and former chief executive, said in the same Boardroom article that New Zealand chief executives in particular are tempted to present perfect reports, because we hate conflict. A report with no problems in it just makes directors ask more questions. Board Intelligence reports that 42 per cent of the directors it surveyed thought management wasn't upfront enough about bad news.
So name the weak point in your proposal before they find it. The cost, the risk, the part you're least sure of. It's the fastest way I know to earn a board's confidence, because confidence isn't something you carry into the room. It's something they decide to have in you.
7. Be ready for the questions
There will be questions, and they may well matter more than the presentation itself. They might come all the way through, from your first sentence. Or the board might hear your summary and then use the rest of the time to question you. Either way, the questions are where a board does its work, so prepare for them as carefully as you prepare what you'll say. Your Obstacles are the place to start.
And when you don't know, say so. The directors and practitioners quoted here all say the same thing: don't bluff. MacCormick's advice is to say you don't know and commit to coming back with the answer, because trust is what you're really there to build.
I'd add three sentences that cover nearly every question you can't fully answer. Say what you know. Say how well you know it. Say what would change your mind.
8. Rehearse it out loud, with someone who'll push
Three times out loud is our rule of thumb for anything that matters, and at least one of those should be in front of colleagues playing the board and asking the questions you're dreading. MacCormick suggests recording yourself and watching it back as a director would. That's what we do, and it's rarely comfortable. But it works.
And then there's AI
It's changing both sides of the table.
On your side, a polished paper has stopped being proof that anyone thought hard about it. Fluency is free now, and every director reading your paper knows it. I've started calling the presenter who turns up with an immaculate deck that isn't really theirs the Outsourcer: information without accountability. A board finds that person out quickly, because the one thing AI can't do is answer the question that comes after the slides. The conversation is where they learn whether the thinking is yours.
On their side, I'd bet a good number of directors now put the board pack into AI and ask for two things: a summary, and the questions they should be asking. That's despite board papers being confidential, which carries risks of its own. The numbers back the hunch. A Diligent Institute survey of US public company directors this year found 82 per cent had used generative AI in their board work in the previous six months, and about 30 per cent had used it to summarise board papers. The Australian Institute of Company Directors reports directors there are already using it to triage packs and draft questions, and its guidance tells them not to treat an AI summary as a substitute for reading the papers themselves.
Three things follow for you. If your paper doesn't open with a clear summary of your own, a machine will write one for them, and it may not be the one you'd have chosen. Expect sharper questions, from page fourteen as well as page one. And do the same thing yourself first: on a tool your organisation has approved for confidential material, ask AI to play a sceptical director and find the holes in your argument. That's what it's best at.
The way I put it in the training room: the Planning is the thinking, the Delivery is the speaking, and Messaging is where AI helps most. It can't decide what you want this board to think, feel and do, and it won't be sitting in your chair when they ask.
Then land it
If you came for a decision, restate the ask once the questions are done, so it's the last thing they hear from you. Then say back what the board has decided and what happens next, so the minutes record what was agreed. Thank them, and go.
If you're the one sending people into that room
If you lead people who present to your board or executive team, you'll already know who this is about. The Boardroom is our programme for them: one day, in-house, for up to ten people, each working on a real paper or presentation of their own, recorded and coached. Everyone presents before morning tea, and we build from there. The aim is people who can hold their own in that room and get their ideas across, without shrinking into the shadows.
Russell Pickering – founder of The Pickering Group, author of Step into the Spotlight.
Sources
1News, RNZ to cut 58 jobs after 'poor and unsustainable' $11.8m loss, 9 November 2026; The Spinoff, RNZ's $11.8m deficit: 'Error after error after error', 10 November 2026
Companies Act 1993, section 138 (use of information and advice)
Institute of Directors (NZ), Top ten tips for better board papers
Institute of Directors (NZ), Boardroom, June/July 2017, Reporting to a board (Rick Christie, Mark Hamilton)
NZ Law Society, LawTalk 949, A view from the top: what the board really, really wants (Pip Greenwood)
Dr Judith MacCormick, Australian Institute of Company Directors, Presenting to the board
Julie Garland McLellan, Presenting to Boards (Great Governance, 2011); AICD, Avoiding a board pack attack; SmartCompany, How to get in and out of a boardroom in one piece
BoardPro webinar, Presenting to boards (Julie Garland McLellan, Megan Motto, Steven Bowman)
Chartered Governance Institute UK & Ireland and Board Intelligence, board reporting guidance, 2026
Diligent Institute and Corporate Board Member, Director Confidence Index, June 2026
Australian Institute of Company Directors, Using AI on board papers: three guardrails for directors, 6 August 2026
Board Intelligence, The state of board effectiveness in 2025
Paul DeNicola and Claudia Montgomery (PwC), Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance, Mastering boardroom communication: five essentials for executives